HomeEntertainmentThe Last of Us Part II: A Case for One of the Greatest Pieces of Media Ever Created

The Last of Us Part II: A Case for One of the Greatest Pieces of Media Ever Created

Published May 21, 2021

By MICHAEL LAKIND

Nearly a full year after its global release, blockbuster video game The Last of Us Part II continues to be a major controversy in gaming for its story, characters and creative process, but it transcends the internet noise to earn its place among the all-time classics. 

(This is an impossible opinion to write without spoilers for both Last of Us games, so be cautious proceeding.) 

Let’s begin with the easiest part: condemning those who created this air of infamy around the game. Very near to the release date, someone leaked huge chunks of gameplay onto YouTube and spoiled Joel’s death. Gamers who hadn’t actually finished the game then took to the internet to complain about how the game is ruined, and due to certain characters’ ethnicity or sexual orientation, creative director Neil Druckmann is “pushing an agenda.” Keep in mind that this is a very watered-down summary. These are the people that must be ignored because they try to blur the line between valid opinion and straight-up bigotry. Plus an onslaught of death threats were sent to Druckmann and to the actors. Deplorable.

Now why is it that people are mad about Abby?

Co-writers Halley Gross and Druckmann took a gargantuan risk with her role in the story and dared the player to turn on their brain and think about what kind of story Naughty Dog is trying to tell. A lot of people couldn’t. Too many people saw this game as trying to hammer in a message against revenge, whereas it truly isn’t even a part of the main equation. Yes, revenge is Ellie’s course of action through Seattle, but the themes of the game are twofold. It tells a story of guilt through the relentless brutality Ellie commits in trying to make up for how she ditched Joel after finding out the truth of the firefly hospital incident, and a story of empathy in Abby’s horrid journey to save Yara and Lev while coming to understand the perspective of those she’d come to hate. Huh, just like the relationship between the player and Abby. Funny how that worked out.

But then why does this 30-hour revenge story not end in revenge? 

Same reason the first game was a 20-hour story about curing the zombie apocalypse that ended with Joel killing the doctors making the cure. The characters’ journeys don’t have to adhere to the premise. By telling an extremely complex dual narrative that intersects itself through changes in perspective, Druckmann and Gross denounce violence by forcing the player to experience the consequences for their own actions. The goal of having Ellie kill Abby’s two best friends (one of which was very pregnant) is to come back after the POV swap and understand the pain inflicted by these characters upon one another. When the player kills these two as Ellie they are fully in support of this action, but when the third day comes around a second time, they feel remorseful when walking in to find their bodies on the floor. All three of the principal characters become the villain in another’s story while trying to be the hero in their own. 

Despite being a landmark piece in gaming history, The Last of Us Part II is widely hated among gamers. (courtesy of Naughty Dog)

So what makes The Last of Us Part II that good?

It’s the most visceral experience I’ve ever witnessed. Druckmann and Gross have this way of holding the player in the palm of their hands, conjuring a wide range of emotions from anger to sadness to fear to shock and even joy. The profoundly gripping nature of this game is something that only video games can achieve because of the interactive accountability for the atrocities onscreen. I went in knowing that Joel was going to die, and even still this scene is morose and heartbreaking to watch, with immense credit going to the actors and animators. Laura Bailey as Abby, Ashley Johnson as Ellie, and Troy Baker as Joel compose perhaps the most prolific cast ever motion-captured, and their harrowing performances leave images and lines in my head that have stuck there for several months. Plain and simple, it does not get any better than these three.

But isn’t it just another zombie shooter game?

On the surface, yes, there are lots of zombies and you kill them with guns. But the main focus is on characters grappling with their humanity. Most of the enemies are uninfected people, and unlike in most shooters, enemies actively beg for their lives or cry out in anguish when their friends are killed. Unlike its predecessor, Part II never stops being able to surprise the player from start to finish. For example, the hospital sequence on Abby’s second day dives deep into survival-horror territory with a climactic fight against the horrifying Rat King, and never grants the player refuge from the boiling sensation in their stomach until the day ends. 

This struggle for humanity also extends to the connection between player and character. At the beginning of the game, Ellie’s path to vengeance is exciting and justified, but as the days pass, she becomes warped and twisted by her hatred, losing sight of what matters most and causing Dina to leave, taking their newborn child with her. When the fog descends over Santa Barbara in the final moments of the game, it is extremely difficult to wish that Ellie finishes the job after everything she and Abby have been through both separately and together. 

But as Matt and Shelby of Girlfriend Reviews explain in their YouTube essay “Understanding The Last of Us Part II,” “there is no difficulty setting in the game, or in life, to make forgiving someone easier.” And so it isn’t out of the question that some people couldn’t connect to the Ellie/Abby dichotomy and each of its many layers, but that level of complexity is what makes revisiting this game and discussing its intricacies so fascinating. 

There is no doubt in my mind that The Last of Us Part II is a monument to artistic achievement and will be remembered for years to come as a game that flipped the table. If you own a PlayStation 4 or 5, this is one of the few true must-haves, especially on PS5 since a performance patch to cut out the need for motion blur was just released on May 19.

No comments

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.