HomeDistrictPre-existing CUSD substitute shortage worsens with COVID-19 variant

Pre-existing CUSD substitute shortage worsens with COVID-19 variant

Published Feb. 3, 2022

BY CLAIRE PETERSON

An increase in the number of absences for both Carmel Unified School District students and teachers due to the omicron variant has exacerbated a substitute teacher shortage across the district.

This fall, CUSD hired three permanent subs who are always on the Carmel High School campus and available. If these substitutes are engaged in work in other classrooms and a teacher needs someone to fill in for their class, the school refers to the district-wide substitute list. 

“Right now, I only substitute at the high school, but in the past everywhere,” substitute teacher Felicia Fisher says. “Because of COVID-19, this is my first year as a full-time sub.”

Fisher substitutes in different classrooms three times a week on average, explaining that it’s beneficial when teachers know they’re going to be out. Substitutes can go in early and the teacher can explain the lesson plans, but when it’s a sudden absence, there isn’t time to do that, which puts the students behind.

Occasionally, teachers are asked to cover in a classroom if other subs are not free.

“If the permanent subs are assigned, and I need another sub, I can call other subs who are on the sub list,” CHS principal’s secretary Lisa Brazil explains. “They sub for all different schools, so sometimes they are and sometimes they aren’t available at the last minute. If I can’t find anybody then I ask other teachers to cover.”

On the list, there are about 10 substitutes designated to teach at the high school level, and certain campus staff with teaching credentials are sometimes asked to sub, but potential strains are placed on teachers’ schedules when they are needed in another classroom.  

“When I’m asked to go sub in another classroom, I’m giving up my prep period,” explains CHS math teacher Jody Roberts, “and I’m not able to complete my work or plan for future lessons.”

Photography teacher Holly Lederle faces the same problem. Lederle explains that giving up a period in which teachers’ time is used for personal work and to better prepare lessons for students affects the quality of their following lessons.

All schools within the district use the same substitutes, so if a majority are needed at the elementary schools or Carmel Middle School, fewer subs remain available to teachers at CHS. 

Superintendent Ted Knight advertised sub positions in a newsletter to the CUSD community last month to help address this shortage. 

Substitute Shannon Bertilacci introduces herself to students while covering for a math class. (Photo by CLAIRE PETERSON)

The substitute shortage has been an ongoing problem for several years prior to the pandemic, and CUSD employees have often rushed to find someone to cover for absent teachers. Despite the spring semester’s increase in the absence of students and faculty members because of the omicron variant, the substitute shortage posed a bigger challenge last semester than it currently does. 

“There are more subs available this semester than there were last semester,” Brazil explains. “People are becoming more comfortable with how the schools are doing and how we’re managing COVID-19. More and more substitutes are calling saying they’re available.”

Many substitutes employed by CUSD have gotten a chance to see the precautions CHS is taking with the new COVID-19 variant and have become more comfortable with the concept of returning to school, but COVID-19 cases have compounded the longstanding problem.

Some teachers, including CHS’ Video Production teacher Brian Granbery, say that it has been more difficult to find a substitute for their classrooms this year in comparison to years prior because of the increased demand. CHS Spanish teacher Tricia Bean is facing similar challenges.

“This year especially, I’ve noticed that it takes longer to find a substitute for my class if I’m out,” Bean explains. “It’s easier if I’m just out for a period or two, but if it’s an entire day it’s harder to find someone who’s available.”

Teachers at CHS can place a request for a substitute through Aesop Online, a program that serves as a substitute absence management primarily for teachers. When teachers are out, they state their reason for absence, and the system randomly generates calls to the substitutes that are available in the district. 

Teachers can also request a specific substitute before one is randomly assigned.

A bachelor’s degree and a substitute teaching credential are required in order to serve as a substitute in the district. Brazil explains that parents with these credentials have also been stepping in as substitutes, which is greatly appreciated.

No comments

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.