Published Feb. 1, 2023
BY MINNA TROKEL
After two years of Zoom-based county competitions, the CHS mock trial team finally headed to the Monterey Courthouse this Tuesday to defend their eight-year streak of winning the county title.
The nationally recognized club, advised by social studies teacher and former federal prosecutor Bill Schrier, has been attending the county-wide competition, consisting of four trials against multiple local teams (currently standing at nine), since the club’s founding in 2004. Schrier, who has coached the team since its beginning, says that despite past experience and success with county competitions, no students on the current team have participated in an in-person one, as the most recent in-person county competition was in 2020, right before the state competition was shut down for the pandemic.
The team’s first in-person competition since then was the invitational Empire Chicago competition in October.
“A part of all of us are nervous because in-person mock trial is a totally different game,” senior witness Maggie Johnston says. “It’s more exciting and you feel it more when it’s in person versus when it’s on screen. The competition is more real.”
The in-person aspect, while appreciated, is felt by many as an added challenge to an already challenging situation, Johnston says. The self-imposed pressure to win felt by many members participating in the yearly county-wide competition stems from the team’s winning streak and the importance of the county competition, which leads to state and then national competitions.

Sophomore Brianna Sciuto testifies at the October Empire competition. (courtesy of EMPIRE CHICAGO)
“We do some other tournaments throughout the year that all ultimately culminate in the county competition,” says club vice president Shayla Dutta.
According to club president Sophia Cho and attorney Emma Brown, both seniors, despite the challenge the team faced of readjusting to online trials, they are well-prepared from both in-person scrimmages across the state and attending the international Empire competition in October.
The CHS mock trial tradition of passing down knowledge and method through the team as a style of teaching newer students how to compete posed a challenge earlier in the school year when many realized that they themselves didn’t remember in-person trial etiquette.
“When we first started doing in-person trials this year, I realized that there was basically no corporate knowledge left,” Schrier says, “and I started to wonder if I even remembered.”
Each member of the team, regardless of grade, showed an excitement and willingness to make the transition from Zoom to in-person trials.
“There was definitely a learning curve, but many people were excited to go back in person, even with all that comes with it,” says Cho, who acts as a trial attorney.

Club president Sophia Cho, co-council Emma Brown and vice president Shalya Dutta (from left) act as the prosecution council in the second round of Empire Chicago. (courtesy of EMPIRE CHICAGO)
One of the many lessons competitors had to learn or relearn was how to physically present themselves to the court, a vital aspect of mock trial previously limited by Zoom.
“The biggest difference is the etiquette,” Cho explains. “In-person trials come with a lot of formalities that you wouldn’t see in Zoom. When to sit, where to stand, where to speak or stand when speaking to the court, are all in consideration, but in Zoom trials, you are turning on and off your camera.”
The fact that students are once again able to maximize the meaning of their movements in the courtroom adds another element of excitement for many participants, who are excited to see how far they can go.
“Ultimately, mock trials should be fun,” Schrier says. “I believe that if you have fun and do your best, then it doesn’t matter how it turns out.”
The county competition ends Feb. 11, and the state competition will be in-person in Los Angeles from March 17-19.