HomeEditors' PicksLanguage program offerings shrink, sparking various concerns among CUSD community

Language program offerings shrink, sparking various concerns among CUSD community

Published November 5, 2026

By RUBY IRANMANESH

Beginning this fall, the Carmel Unified School District has made several changes to its language department, including the elimination of the French program at Carmel Middle School and the Chinese program across all schools, triggering disapproval among students, parents and teachers concerned about the impact of these cuts on language learning opportunities.

These curriculum changes were made during the second semester of the 2025-26 school year after French and Chinese experienced a decrease in enrollment. Spanish is now the only language option for students up until CHS, which currently offers French and American Sign Language as well. 

“The decision to discontinue French classes at CMS was complex and involved looking at student interest, enrollment numbers, staffing, scheduling and the overall elective opportunities available to students,” says CMS principal Daniel Morgan. “While we would love to offer a wide variety of courses, the reality is that we have to consider a variety of factors in the scheduling process.”

Morgan emphasizes that CMS plans to keep French 1 on the elective selection sheet for students, and if student interest increases, they will approach the district about bringing the class back for the 2027-28 school year.

The district says that the decision to discontinue French courses at CMS for the 2026-27 school year does not represent a predetermined decision about the future of French within CUSD, adding that information on world languages will be presented at the Nov. 18 board meeting.

For more than 40 years, CMS offered French. Chinese was added in 2007. The reduction of the French program and elimination of Chinese mark a major shift for the district, and many community members—including language teachers—believe these recent decisions will negatively affect students moving forward.

“The elimination of French at CMS also has long-term consequences for the French program at CHS,” said CHS French teacher Suzanne Marden at May’s board meeting. “Middle school world language programs allow students to accelerate their learning and create flexibility in high school schedules. Without that opportunity, students may be forced into a single language pathway for all four years of high school in order to reach proficiency goals, limiting their elective opportunities and increasing schedule constraints.”

For the 2025-26 school year, French 1 had 13 students enrolled and French 2 had 15. The year before, French 1 had 23 students and French 2 had 13 students.

“Of the 13 students enrolled in French 1 last year, only seven CMS students signed up for French 2, and we only had six or seven students sign up for French 1,” says Morgan. “With those numbers, we simply could not justify running the program this year.”

CHS counselors emphasize the benefits of having high school level languages offered at the middle school, particularly for students seeking language acquisition or planning to apply to competitive universities. 

“All the counselors are really in favor of keeping high school levels of language at the middle school,” explains CHS counselor Jeff Rogers. “We really wanted to keep starting these programs in seventh and eighth grade so that students can become global citizens and truly develop the language skills needed to be successful.”

Several CUSD language teachers have also voiced that these recent changes felt abrupt. 

“I don’t feel like it was communicated well to language teachers, students or families,” says CHS Spanish teacher Tricia Bean, who also spoke out at two recent board meetings. “I also don’t feel like all of the stakeholders were involved in the decision to eliminate Chinese from CUSD or French at the middle school.”

CMS French teacher Janine Olin, who spent last year on sabbatical studying French abroad to aid her instruction, says she was also surprised to learn that CUSD was cutting the CMS French program. 

“When I reached out to the administration in February because I was really looking forward to coming back to CMS, I was not at all prepared for them to say that they were cutting the program,” explains Olin. “I was told that CMS was no longer going to support French and that I would be doing something else.”

After hearing this, Olin asked to take another leave of absence for the 2026-27 school year.

“I think it was communicated to other people that they were cutting French because I wasn’t coming back from leave,” says Olin. “But that’s not how it happened. Overall, I don’t think it was handled well, and I don’t think this decision is supported by the community.”

When her leave of absence is finished, Olin plans to return to CUSD next school year, but it remains unclear what her job will be. With Marden set to retire in June, a French teaching position at CHS will be opening up. 

“I am very disappointed that there was not a public discussion about the French program being canceled at CMS,” explains CUSD parent Cronan Murphy-O’Connor. “I don’t believe I ever received notification that it wasn’t going to be continued at the middle school. I just found out through rumors, and then I was able to confirm with some of the teachers.”

While the removal of French felt abrupt for many, the phaseout of Chinese was gradual. The process began two years ago with the elimination of the Chinese program at CMS and continued this year with its removal from CHS. 

“I have so many great memories,” says Joyce Liu, the previous CUSD Chinese teacher. “For 10 years, before COVID-19, we had a field trip to China during February break with parent and colleague volunteers, and we used to go on local field trips to Chinese restaurants. Because the kids stayed with me for three to four years, they were like a small family.”

Currently, Liu is working as an academic support teacher at CMS.

Although the French program at Carmel Middle School once offered international trips, such as the 2023 trip to Paris, middle schoolers will not have this opportunity for now. courtesy of JANINE OLIN

“It’s really sad that Chinese is not being offered anymore because Ms. Liu had a really great program growing even though a lot of students didn’t do it,” says CHS senior Lola Voss, who completed Chinese 4 Honors. “I had four other students in my class, and because it was such a small group, we got really personalized feedback.”

In terms of French, there are currently six CMS eighth-grade students enrolled in French 2 who take the bus to CHS every day to attend the first-period class. Marden expresses that continuing this into next year could be helpful to younger students hoping to attain their Seal of Biliteracy or reach AP French.

“Having the eighth-graders here first period is really working out,” explains Marden. “I’m wondering if we could do the same thing with level one and offer it to eighth-graders. That would help their accessibility at levels four and five, and it’s a nicer path.”

CHS currently offers five levels of French: French 1-3, French 4 Honors and AP French. In the future, it is possible that the district may remove either AP French or French 4 Honors to ensure that students will be able to complete all levels of the program within their high school career.

“When you look at our language program, it’s a five-year program,” says Rogers. “It’s not a four-year program. So if we don’t start it in eighth-grade, students can’t complete AP. This is something we’re very concerned about.”

Apart from teachers and parents expressing concern, many students have also voiced their opinions about this decision. CHS senior Eli David even began a change.org petition in May against the removal of French at CMS, attracting 260 signatures as of Nov. 1.

“I started this petition because I simply could not let myself do nothing to reverse this unjustified decision,” explains David, who completed AP French last year. “The French program at CMS is not just about learning a language. It’s about cultural exchange, understanding and fostering global awareness among middle school students.”

No comments

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.