Published Feb. 1, 2023
BY EMMA BROWN
After Brazilian President Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva took office Jan. 1, supporters of former President Jair Bolsonaro stormed the government buildings a week later to protest what the mob falsely claimed to be a rigged election. The mass attack occurred two years after the American insurrection on Jan. 6, 2021, during which supporters of former President Donald Trump stormed the Capitol Building to rally against the same conspiracy theory.
To those who believe in the myth of widespread election fraud, the actions of the protestors were not only ethical, but also were warranted, raising questions about if and when it is moral to overthrow the government.
The right to resist is often the defense for coups or revolutionary action, with insurrectionists claiming that they have an inherent right to fight against tyranny or injustice. On its face, the natural law certainly seems to validate that sort of behavior; however, nuances to the right limit circumstances in which it can be invoked. Citizens are justified in rebellion only when injustice rises to a high level, making life intolerable. Oxford University’s Regius Professor of Civil Law Tony Honoré claimed that there were only three circumstances in which the right to resist could be used: when an oppressed group wants a change in government, when the people want to resist a change in government or when the people seek to secure independence.
Most importantly, the right to resist seeks to restore legal order and enforce constitutional standards rather than restructuring an entire political landscape. By invoking the doctrine, other essential rights must become more secure.
Had the Brazilian and American elections truly been rigged by a government entity, with that action resulting in widespread injustice, rioters would have been morally justified in their actions. Yet the foundation for their actions were baseless conspiracy theories, making their efforts to seize political power disruptive, illegal and pointless. Perceived injustice does not legitimize extreme, violent action.
British philosopher Thomas Hobbes believed that societies functioned because of a social contract, an unspoken set of agreements among citizens to give up freedoms for the purpose of safety. Without it, society would crumble. And without society, humans would revert to a state of nature where they would act on base instincts.
According to Hobbes, the sovereign or ruler of a particular civilization needs to have ultimate authority to keep citizens in line, thus giving the people no right to resist the government’s authority. When experiencing injustice, the only moral course of action would be to abandon the social contract and return to a state of nature, though the prospect is unappealing at best. As such, the Brazilian and American protestors would have no grounds for their violent actions, and if widespread injustice had truly been present, the groups should have instead sought to dissolve their respective societies entirely.
Had there actually been widespread election fraud, the appropriate action for dissenters would have been civil disobedience, a practice that John Rawls outlined as being public, nonviolent action done with the intention of changing a law. Most importantly, civil disobedience must be well-founded. As a result, if the demonstrators had taken to the streets to protest their false claims of a stolen election, even peacefully, their actions would have been immoral.
Acting within the law is essential to the purpose of civil disobedience because the protest is meant to respectfully communicate dissent to oppressors. Storming capitol buildings, killing security guards and destroying government property clearly violates that principle.
The actions of the rioters who stormed Brazil’s executive, Congress and Supreme Court buildings were unequivocally unethical, as the basis for their revolt was entirely unfounded and, as a result, their violence entirely unjustified.