Published Mar. 10, 2022
By FLINT NACHBAR
To new residents, Carmel Valley has always been an 11-mile stretch full of upper-class housing and boujee wineries. With its beautiful scenery and extensive opportunities for hiking, fishing and biking, it is not surprising to long-time residents that Carmel Valley has become a desirable destination to live.
That desirability leads to higher property values and more money in the area, but some of Carmel Valley’s residents have experienced the valley before any money came to the area.
Local valley resident Cody West gives an understanding of what it was like growing up in the valley in the early 1980s.
“It was definitely more blue collar back then,” West remembers. “It was full of artists and hippies; definitely more lowkey.”
Cody West tells stories of him and his friends riding their dirt bikes along the Carmel River, or as he refers to it, “our super-highway, back then, before we had cars.” Roaming the valley clearly played a large role in his childhood as West would leave his home in the morning and often not come home until dark. West claims that the increase of wealth within Carmel Valley comes from the popularity of Carmel.

Cody West (far right) showing how the Valley started with farmers and ranchers. (courtesy of CODY WEST)
“I’m sure a lot of people got exposed to the valley after planning trips to Carmel,” West says. “Carmel has always been wealthy.”
With Carmel getting more exposure, Carmel Valley started to get more attention from people with money, causing, in his words, “the valley to lose its edge.”
“Carmel Valley was pretty sleepy when I was a kid,” West says. “Nothing but a bunch of old pickup trucks, and I guess I miss it that way.”
West says that life was simpler when he was growing up. During his childhood he found a community out in the valley, and although he still has a strong connection with his family and a few close friends, he says that the wealth causes people to become more isolated.
“I’ll be driving and I’ll see some of the old boys in their 4×4 trucks going out to Cachagua,” West reflects, “and I appreciate that they are still here, and it makes me reminisce about when I was a kid.”
Long-time resident Aram Stoney notes the changes he has seen in Carmel Valley.
“The biggest thing that I noticed was a decrease in affordability,” Stoney says. “You definitely weren’t seeing Mercades and BMWs rolling around town.”
According to Stoney the increase in wealth has not necessarily affected the rustic feel of the valley, but he claims that may change.
“There haven’t been a lot of visual changes to the valley,” Stoney says. “Luckily not a lot of building growth.”
But Stoney points to the recently approved development plans to put housing units on Rancho Quinata as a change brought about by the wealth in the area.
Another Local resident Kristan Roth has a different take on things.
“There is a lot more wealth in the area now,” Roth says, “but the type of people that Carmel Valley attracts are people that want to connect with nature and experience nature.”

At the mouth of the valley, Aram Stoney attended Carmel High School as a student growing up in Carmel Valley. (courtesy of ARAM STONEY)
Roth says that this has kept Carmel Valley’s population very down to Earth, but because Carmel Valley attracts many nature lovers it leads to the overcrowding of spots like Garland State Park and other hiking and river spots. She feels that the overcrowding should not be viewed as something that is entirely negative.
“The draw to be in beautiful spots in nature is wonderful,” Roth says. “It’s just how you stay in alignment with being a good human and taking care of nature.”
She also says that despite the wealth that is now present in the area, the valley still has some of its rustic charm, just in a different way, claiming that the wealthy people in the area are attracted to the rustic feel of the valley.
“When I was a kid I’d see horses tied to the post at the village market,” Roth says. “And just the other day I spotted a couple horses going down the road, so it’s here but it’s just different.”
Roth does admit after spending her childhood in the valley it’s strange to see people going to the new vineyards and “rolling in their expensive cars.”
“But they’re just living their lives,” Roth says. “And checking out our country life-style.”
Jerry Kurz, a community member who grew up in Carmel Valley Village, also has stories of how Carmel Valley has changed since his childhood, growing up by the river and at the baseball park out in the village. He tells stories about his free reign over the Carmel Valley River.
“Everybody fished,” Kurz explains. “I would go down to the river and see 10 pickup trucks, and to this day I can still remember steelhead trout flopping in the beds of peoples trucks, you just don’t see that anymore.”
Besides the scarcity of trout in the Carmel River, Jerry Kurz mentioned other things that had changed since he was a kid.
“You don’t have as much agriculture out here,” Kurz says. “And you have a different class of people working here now than you did 30 years ago.”
Kurz also argues that the wealth has not affected his ability to find a community out in the valley.
“I’m pretty lucky because I do have a lot of close friends that are still in the area,” Kurz says, “so there is definitely a community here.”
Carmel Valley is a perfect example of a community that transitioned from the middle class to upper class, and ethier people see that as a beneficial or negative thing, it has not seemed to put too much strain on the valley community itself.
As Kurz says, “Carmel Valley is always going to be Carmel Valley.”